Buying or Renting in 2027? (The 7% Rule)

Loading player...
Join my masterclass: learn.moneywithcarla.com/invest

Is it actually better to buy property or rent and invest the difference? I ran the numbers so you don't have to. Again.

In this video I break down the buy vs rent debate properly, including the 7% rule, real property growth rates, and how stock market returns compare over the long run. The answer might surprise you.

What I cover:
- The true cost of buying (it's more than just your bond repayment
- How the 7% rule works and whether it actually holds up against
- Property growth vs stock market returns, side by side
- When buying makes financial sense, and when renting wins
- What the numbers say about which option leaves you better off

This is one of the biggest financial decisions you'll ever make.

👇 Watch to the end, the comparison at the end changed how I think about this.
🔔 Subscribe for honest, no-fluff money content every week.
Chapters
  • 00:29 The 7% Rule
  • 03:03 Property vs Stock Market Growth
  • 04:12 The 7% Return
  • 08:41 The 7% Rule in Practice
  • 08:55 The Annual Cost of Renting
  • 09:19 The Break-Even Rent
  • 09:29 Buying vs Renting: The Monthly Cost
  • 09:34 The R46K Monthly Difference
13 Oct English South Africa Investing

Other recent episodes

RAs Are NOT For Everyone

Does a retirement annuity’s tax saving automatically make it the best investment? Carla compares RAs with investing directly in global equity ETFs, exploring tax, investment restrictions, fees and how your time to retirement changes the picture. Using Laura and Nora’s investment scenarios, she explains the trade-offs, flags expensive life insurance…
4 Oct 16 min

Estate & Trusts (Tax Expert Is Back)

This week I sit down with Marisca, a tax expert, to unpack trusts and estate planning in South Africa. We chat about when a trust makes sense, common mistakes, and how to plan ahead to protect the wealth you leave to your family.
27 Sep 44 min

Big Name Funds Underperform. What are you paying for?

Get my book here: https://www.moneywithcarla.com/book Free Investment Masterclass: https://learn.moneywithcarla.com/masterclass2026 Most South Africans are losing hundreds of thousands of rands in household-name investment funds, without even realising it. In this video I compare real fund performance from two of my students against equivalent ETFs, and show you exactly how to benchmark…
20 Sep 6 min

Anzel Rabie | Stellenbosch & Afrikaans Money-Culture

Find Anzel on socials: https://www.instagram.com/anzelrabie/?hl=en What does a CA who almost became Miss SA have to teach us about generational wealth? More than you'd expect. In this episode, I sit down with Anzel – chartered accountant turned TV personality and mom of two – to talk about the money lessons…
11 Sep 37 min

To DIY or not? EasyEquities Expert Answers Your Questions.

What’s really happening inside your investment account and how do you know the platform holding it is trustworthy? In this episode, I sit down with the Higgo van Biljon from EasyEquities to unpack how the platform works, what investors actually own, and the questions that matter before you invest. We…
6 Sep 42 min