Growing resistance against Stalingrad legal defence – Prof Pierre de Vos

Loading player...
The battle to remove South Africa’s Public Protector, Advocate Busisiwe Mkhwebane, took four years and consumed more than R160 million of taxpayers' money, with her legal defence bent on dragging out the case and delaying her removal, employing every unethical and ethical legal tactic to avoid being held accountable. This tactic, known as the Stalingrad defence, has also been repeatedly employed by former President Jacob Zuma’s legal team to evade accountability. However, recently, this type of litigation suffered significant blows: President Zuma lost his private prosecution case against Advocate Billy Downer, and News24 journalist Karyn Maughan, and Advocate Mkhwebane was finally removed from her position as Public Protector. In an interview with Biznews, Constitutional law lecturer Pierre de Vos said that the Stalingrad defence strategy raises broader questions about South Africa’s legal system and the need for reforms to prevent the abuse of procedural rules in court cases. De Vos added that this tactic is not limited to the political field; it is a broader problem in the private sector where big companies and individuals with deep pockets undermine justice. Nevertheless, De Vos expressed optimism noting a shift in South African courts’ approach, indicating growing resistance against the Stalingrad defence. He said in recent court cases lawyers have been ordered to cover the cost of delays.
20 Sep 2023 8AM English South Africa Investing · Business News

Other recent episodes

BN Edge | Sean Peche: Nvidia, Anthropic, Tencent, Adobe, the rand, the UK

Plenty of investors looked at Nvidia's slump after Jensen Huang's resignation and saw a bargain. Ranmore founder Sean Peche told Alec Hogg he saw a storm. On the day the chipmaker was due to report, he explained why ten times earnings only looked cheap if Nvidia could more than double…
17 Nov 7AM 42 min

Madlanga & Mkhwanazi: The protection routes are drying up

In his latest interview with Chris Steyn, Willem Els of the Security Initiative for Africa (SIA) says there is a lot of pressure on President Cyril Ramaphosa to act against Special Leave Minister Senzo Mchunu amid suspicions that he and former Deputy National Commissioner General Shadrack Sibiya handed over "replacement"…
17 Nov 7AM 14 min

Richard Chelin: Beware hidden coalition agreements and political fairy stories

In this interview with Chris Steyn, Independent Governance Expert Richard Chelin advises ratepayers which Red Flags look out for once municipal coalitions have been formed. "Business owners, investors, and everyday taxpayers need to look past the political spin and watch for very practical indicators; look out for the red flags….look…
16 Nov 9AM 13 min

Ambassador Femi Fani-Kayode: Sinister forces are working to destroy South Africa…

In this wide-ranging interview with Chris Steyn, Nigeria’s new Ambassador to South Africa, His Excellency Chief Femi Fani-Kayode, warns that there are sinister forces at work that are trying to destabilise South Africa. “My view is that there are subterranean forces at work trying to divide South Africa and destroy…
16 Nov 4AM 27 min